All Sport Is Unfair, According to Geneticist. Is That True?

Theral Timpson

Yesterday a court ruled that the South African running sensation Caster Semenya must take medication to lower her level of testosterone to compete in certain women only running events such as the 400 and 800 meters.

Some are calling the ruling discrimination against a certain athlete or against transgener or intersex athletes.  Some say the ruling is necessary to keep the sport fair.  It’s a worthy debate.  

What I find particularly useful about the debate is what it tells us about how our colleagues in the science community are thinking.

Geneticist and media personality Adam Rutherford tweeted:

The assumption behind this tweet is that fairness is a quality that is determined by biology.   Let’s say for just a moment that we went with this assumption.  How would we determine its validity?  How would we get into the position to determine it?  Let’s say we could devise a “great scale” where one could measure all the molecules of each individual person.  Or would it be a scanner?  Would it be a sequencer?  What would it be?  Would it be an HPLC instrument or all of the above?  Would it help to have Craig Venter on hand?  How would we measure each and every molecule of each top athlete and compare them with each other?  Where is—or who is—this biological deity which can see through us and determine our biological “fitness” to compete?  

Furthermore, are we able to reduce all competitive qualities to molecules?

In other words, this debate over sports fairness is another iteration of the biology reductionism debate.  It appears (I'm in the middle of two of his books about humans and their genetic makeup) Rutherford is a reductionist.  For him, it looks like all of biology can be explained by physics.  And every athlete’s performance can be explained by molecules.  All sports by the science of biology.

And many in his following agree.  One of them, a Martin Waring, tweeted: 

"Michael Phelps shouldn’t haven’t been allowed to compete at swimming as his size 14 feet and flexible ankles gave him an unfair advantage.   He also had unnatural arm reach.”

Phelps achievement has been reduced here to physical biological qualities.  There is no acknowledgment of any of Phelps’s perserverance, his skill, his determination, his work ethic.  No.  He is the sum total of his bodily parts.

Is there anything more to competitive sport than measurements and parts?  It's like saying the great Chicago Bulls team from the 90's that brought home six championships that decade was just a combination of their feet, legs, hands, reach, and jump height!  What about skilll, strategy, an amazing coach who went on to do some magic with the LA Lakers--and, let's ask about the big one, what about imagination?!  Has there ever been a great performance without a dynamic, creative imagination at work?

To the question about fairness being a quality that is determined by biology,  let me offer some alternatives there as well.  Fairness might also be created by the agreement of the players to compete.  When a group of young kids come together in the street for a pick-up game of soccer, is it not a fair game?  They immediately and intuitively size each other up and agree to a game.  The agreement itself generates the fairness.  If they see that one is older, bigger, “out of their league” they will automatically exclude this person.  Fairness may also be created from the very rules of a game.  While it may be true that life is unfair, sport is our way of creating a temporary “fair” space.  

In Semenya's case the issue of fairness will be decided by the community, just as it is in the pick-up soccer game on the street, and the sport will go on.

The drive by biologists to reduce competitive drive and success in sports (or music or other pursuits) to smaller ingredients is admittedly vigorous and complex.  But it is not only complex in the way they seem to suggest:  we just don’t have enough machines and data and PhDs yet to figure it out.  

You can have machines and biological data stacked to the moon.  This will never get you more than so far.


modafinil order modafinil <a href=" ">modafinil smart drug </a> modafinil drug test

modafinil india how to get modafinil prescription <a href=" ">modafinil 100mg </a> sunosi vs modafinil

provigil for adhd [url= ]goodrx modafinil [/url] provigil 100mg modafinil otc

provigil for sale - buy modafinil online goodrx modafinil modafinil side effects

buy modalert reddit <a href=" ">modafinil 100mg </a> provigil medication

adderall vs modafinil sunosi vs modafinil <a href=" ">modafinil withdrawal </a> modafinil 100mg

modafinil 100mg - modalert reddit modalert online <a href=" ">buy modalert online </a> modafinil reddit

provigil uses <a href=" ">modafinil prescription online </a> provigil generic

modafinil side effects provigil half life <a href=" ">modalert vs modvigil </a> how to get modafinil prescription modafinil over the counter modafinil and alcohol <a href=" ">modafinil reddit </a> nuvigil vs provigil

provigil and alcohol provigil and alcohol <a href=" ">modafinil and alcohol </a> how to get modafinil prescription

lowest cost cialis
canada viagra <a href="">canadian pharmacy cialis</a> generic female viagra cialis and pharmacy <a href= cialis reviews</a> viagra soft tabs <a href=" viagra in canada</a> online rx <a href=>viagra online shop</a>
canadian pharmacy com <a href="">cialis canada</a> viagra prescriptions viagra canada with prescription <a href=>viagra from canadian pharmacy</a>
buy levitra canada <a href="">viagra plus</a> generic cialis canadian canadian pharmacies generic drugs online <a href=>cialis without a prescription</a> viagra india <a href="">viagra expiration date</a> price of cialis canada best generic cialis <a href=>canadian rx</a>
viagra canadian <a href="">canada online drugs</a> approved canadian online pharmacies buy viagra without prescription canada <a href= pharmacy viagra</a>

viagra online cheap
cialis in canada <a href=" pharmacy</a> cheap viagra generic how to buy viagra <a href= meds</a> viagra 100 <a href=" canada</a> tadalafil india pharmacy cialis from canada? <a href=>herbal viagra</a>
canadian generic viagra <a href="">canadian pills online</a> viagra cheapest price viagra buy online <a href=>presc... codes</a>

how to use viagra
generic cialis online pharmacy <a href="">best price for generic cialis</a> viagra mexico canadian pharmacies for viagra <a href=>... viagra</a> natural viagra <a href="">discount tadalafil</a> buy viagra without prescription canada viagra in india <a href=>cialis pharmacy rx one</a>
buy viagra <a href=" does viagra work</a> generic cialis buy viagra online without prescription <a href=>buy viagra online cheap</a>

canada online pharmacies
buy drugs online <a href="">cheap viagra for sale</a> candida viagra best canadian pharmacies shipping to usa <a href=>canadian medication</a> canadian-pharcharmy <a href=" generic viagra online</a> baclofen cheap generic viagra online <a href=>viagra buy</a> <a href=" canadian pharmacy</a> online drugs canadian online pharmacy viagra <a href=>buy viagra generic</a>

natural alternatives to viagra
canadian pharmacies without a prescription <a href="">discount meds</a> lowest cost cialis order cialis in canada [url=]viagra and high blood pressure[/url] lowest prescription prices <a href=" pharmacy viagra</a> canada ed meds online [url=]my canadian pharmacy[/url]
cialis on canada <a href="">viagra online in canada</a> supermarket near me best price viagra [url=]buy cheap viagra online uk[/url]

viagra sale
the canadian pharmacy <a href="">where to buy viagra</a> canadian rx prices universal drugstore [url=]viagra online shop[/url] cialis and pharmacy <a href="">my canadian pharmacy</a> canada prescription no prescription pharmacy [url= viagra[/url]
viagra online order <a href=";area=forumprofile;u=587... cost cialis</a> ed drugs viagra sales online [url=]pink viagra[/url]

generic drugs
viagra wiki <a href="">cheap viagra online</a> cialis coupon for pharmacy viagra pharmacy <a href= pharmacy and cialis</a> purchasing viagra from canada <a href=" cialis generic how to buy viagra <a href=;area=forumprofile>viagra online order</a>
generic cialis online pharmacy <a href="">where can i get viagra without a prescription</a> canadian <a href=>canadian pharcharmy</a>

best online canadian prescription companies
canada for viagra <a href="">purchase viagra online</a> cialis from usa pharmacy drug store [url= cost cialis[/url] my canadian pharmacies <a href="">viagra directions</a> purchasing viagra from canada over the counter viagra alternative [url=]ed canadian pharmacy[/url]
viagra 100mg <a href="">viagra professional</a> ordering viagra best price on cialis 5mg [url=]viagra facts[/url]

ordering viagra
buying drugs from canada <a href="">canadian rx</a> canadian pharmacy cialis generic discount viagra online [url= canadian pharcharmy online[/url] buy viagra online without script <a href="">buy drugs online</a> canada online pharmacy viagra cheapest viagra [url=]generic cialis[/url]
viagra samples free <a href="">cialis canada</a> what is viagra viagra free samples [url=][/url]

medication prices
online pharmacy usa <a href=" cheap</a> viagra prescriptions free viagra sample [url=]viagra plus[/url] canadian prescriptions <a href="">generic brand viagra</a> canadian meds [url= drug mart[/url]
cheap viagra without prescription <a href=";area=forump... cheap viagra</a> buying cialis canada [url=]how much does cialis cost[/url]

canadian pharmacy for viagra
viagra by mail <a href="">brand name viagra</a> generic brand viagra viagra order online [url=]canada pharmacies[/url] cialis and pharmacy <a href=""... canadian pharmacy-viagra free trial of viagra [url=]cialis online from canada[/url]
viagra for cheap <a href="">c... online pharmacies</a> canadian drugs canadian rx [url=]cheap cialis online canadian pharmacy[/url]

buy brand cialis online canada
viagra pill <a href="">canadian-meds</a> cialis without prescription canada non prescription viagra [url=]cialis cost[/url] where to buy viagra <a href="">northwest canadian pharcharmy online</a> cheap cialis online canada pharmacy viagra professional [url=]where can i get viagra without a prescription[/url]
cialis cheap canada <a href="">female viagra pills</a> cheap cialis online canada pharmacy canadian cialis] [url=]buy drugs without a prescription[/url]

cialis coupon for pharmacy
genuine viagra <a href="">cialis of canada</a> buy canadian drugs without prescription buy viagra in canada [url= viagra[/url] cheap viagra uk <a href="">ci... us pharmacy cialis brand viagra online canada pharmacy [url= for cialis[/url]
viagra overdose <a href="">online generic viagra</a> canada pharmacy for viagra viagra in india [url= drug company[/url]

viagra overnight
online drug <a href="">canadian drug store</a> viagra online in canada lowest prescription prices [url=]drugs without a prescription[/url] canadian pharmacies viagra <a href="">canadian pharmacies without a prescription</a> cialis for daily use canada canada walmart [url=]cheap viagra from india[/url]
free viagra pills <a href="">viagra results</a> cialis canadian pharmacies viagra side effects [url= natural[/url]

viagra online canada
pharma from canada <a href="">viagra plus</a> women taking viagra canadian meds [url=]is there a generic cialis[/url] canadian pharmacies without prescriptions <a href="">online pharmacies in canada</a> buy viagra uk pharmacy viagra [url=]get viagra[/url]
canadian rx pharmacy <a href="">viagra pharmacy</a> baclofen viagra cheap [url=]viagra for men[/url]

generic viagra canada
cialis in canada <a href="">canadian pharmacy online viagra</a> viagra natural price of viagra [url=\]canadian prescription[/url] <a href="">canadian pharmacy - cialis</a> by pills from canada real viagra online [url=]canadian pharmacies without prescriptions[/url]
about canadian drug companies <a href="">tadalafil in canada</a> real viagra canada pharmacies online prescriptions [url=]tadalafil canada[/url]

cheap viagra generic
price of cialis canada <a href="">cheap viagra</a> cost of cialis drugs canada [url= how viagra works <a href="">canadian rx</a> low cost viagra purchase viagra online [url= purchase online[/url]
best price for generic cialis <a href="">viagra soft</a> ordering viagra generic viagra in canada [url=]pur... cialis from canada[/url]

calais pills from canada
viagra sales <a href="">buy viagra from canada</a> canadian pharmacies generic drugs online ordering medications from canada [url= patent expiration[/url] do you need a prescription for viagra in canada <a href="">low price cialis</a> cheap cialis in canada viagra women [url=]canadian cialis][/url]
how to take viagra <a href=" sale</a> buy viagra online without prescription buy medication without an rx [url= canada online pharmacy[/url]
viagra online without prescription <a href="">order cialis in canada</a> viagra free sample generic viagra in canada [url=]hydrocodone[/url] <a href=" prescription viagra</a> cialis without a doctor's prescription canadian pharmacy and viagra [url=;area=forumprofile;u=1... order online[/url]
viagra prices <a href="">canada online pharmacy viagra</a> canadian pharcharmy online reviews drugstore online [url=;... pills[/url]

cheap viagra online canada pharmacy
viagra dosage <a href=" pharcharmy online without prescription</a> tadalafil canada buy viagra new york [url=]buy viagra from canada[/url] buy cialis online canada pharmacy <a href="">canada drug prices</a> costco pharmacy viagra online cheap [url=]canada pharmacies[/url]
cialis from canada? <a href="">viagra canada</a> generic pharmacy india how much does cialis cost [url=]order viagra without prescription[/url]

cialis - canada
ephedrine sulfate <a href="">canadian pharmacy meds</a> how much does viagra cost drug world canada [url= viagra in canada[/url] cheap canadian viagra <a href=" medication without an rx</a> viagra overdose canadian drugstore [url= store[/url]
viagra online shop <a href=" pharma</a> cheap medications canadian generic viagra [url=\]purchase viagra in canada[/url]

5 mg cialis canada
buy viagra online without script <a href="">cialis and pharmacy</a> buy viagra without a prescription canadian pharmacy online for viagra [url=]cialis from.canada[/url] viagra jelly <a href="">viagra pill</a> best canadian drugstore no prescription pharmacy [url= viagra from canada[/url]
canadian pharmacy online viagra <a href="">canadian generic viagra</a> canadian.cialis viagra.canada [url=]alcohol and viagra[/url]

erectile dysfunction drugs online
generic pharmacy <a href="">generic viagra india</a> natural viagra alternatives cialis without prescription canada [url=]viagra online canadian pharmacy[/url] cialis from canada? <a href="">cheap viagra pills</a> cialis from canada canada drug stores [url=]drugs without a prescription[/url]
viagra online prescription <a href="">cialis from.canada</a> buy lsd online viagra online in canada [url=]cialis on canadian pharmacy[/url]

uk viagra sales
viagra pills for sale <a href="">canada pharmacies online viagra</a> generic cialis in canada viagra cheapest [url=]cialis over the counter in canada[/url] buy drugs in canada <a href=" viagra from canada</a> buy canadian drugs without prescription meds canada [url=]viagra tablets[/url]
canadian pharmaceuticals <a href=" effects of viagra</a> canadian viagra online pharmacy cheap generic drugs [url=]cheap cialis online canada pharmacy[/url]

generic viagra sale
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa <a href=" viagra in canada</a> cialis canada cheapest viagra [url=]best canadian online pharmacy reviews[/url] canadian pharmacies generic drugs online <a href="">cana... government approved pharmacies</a> buying medications in canada [url=]cialis canada[/url]
viamedic .com <a href="">about canadian drug companies</a> viagra cheapest price how much does viagra cost [url=]canada drug companies[/url]

brand name viagra
canadian pharmacy without a prescription <a href="">ed drugs - canada</a> buy online viagra viagra overnight delivery [url= online pharmacy viagra[/url] real viagra online <a href=" pharmacies viagra</a> viagra india viagra uk [url= canadian pharcharmy online[/url]
cialis best price <a href="">viagra dose</a> canada med cialis of canada [url=]canada drug stores[/url]

viagra usa
canadian-pharmacy-online <a href="">viagra pharmacy</a> medication online viagra at canadian pharmacy [url=]london pharmacy canada[/url] safe generic viagra <a href="">usa pharmacy online</a> buy drugs best canadian pharmacies shipping to usa [url=]cialis pharmacy[/url]
viagra pills for sale <a href="">order cialis from canada</a> canadian online pharmacy for cialis cialis low price [url=]generic cialis from canada[/url]

sildenafil canada
natural viagra <a href="">viagra directions</a> cialis online pharmacy price of cialis in canada [url= canadian pharmacy[/url] cheap generic viagra <a href="">best prices for cialis</a> walmart prescription prices [url=]get viagra[/url]
drugs canada <a href=" prescription</a> shopping online canada canadian cialis reviews [url=]drugs without a prescription[/url]

New to Mendelspod?

We advance life science research, connecting people and ideas.
Register here to receive our newsletter.

or skip signup