George Church Has a Point. Do With the Messenger What You Will, Lulu and Nana Are Here.


Author: 
Theral Timpson

When we first encounter Frankenstein in Mary Shelley’s classic, the scientist has lost all his friends, his wife, his meaning in life because of his science. Now he is frozen half to death out on the sea ice chasing his creation of “gigantic stature” toward the North Pole. It’s the only thing he knows to do. Monster and creator, they are locked in an obsessive battle of existence, creation and loss, birth and death. They both know one thing surely. They have known it all along. There is no going back.

Not actually reading the book until some years ago, I always thought that Frankenstein was the monster. In fact, Frankenstein is the name of the scientist. The author invites a parallel confusion throughout the tale between the scientist and his creation. We are constantly made to wonder who is the stranger one. The “monster” at times sounds quite human: tender, impressionable and rational.

This past week we heard of a scientist “going rogue” in Southern China editing a gene--the germline--of two actual new humans, or as we science journalists so bluntly put it, creating “the world’s first CRISPRed babies.” Yet the way he went about it has led us all to condemn the scientist as stranger than the science. His rebellion has allowed us to hide our fear of this fantastic and utterly terrifying technology behind our outrage.

A few days on, are we still in denial?

There’s no question that He Jiankui has done some improper medicine and some questionable science with some pretty good technology. I say improper medicine, but not ineffective medicine because if it didn't work (think of stem cell clinics in Mexico) then there wouldn't be much reaction. It's precisely because we think it worked that we are so afraid. And the reaction from around the genomics community has been swift: a combination of bewilderment, shock, rage, condemnation and wonder since we read Antonio Regalado's piece in Tech Review on Sunday. “Wait a minute . . this is not what it was supposed to look like.” Even though it's not what we might have envisioned, it is the headline for which we were all waiting. We might want to attack the messenger, but the message is still here.

It certainly was surreal as we watched He Jiankui announce this biggest of all medical breakthroughs from a Youtube video. Breaking with standard ethical protocols, he seemed to be making it up as he went along. An app would have done a better informed consent. "Families need this technology," he argued directly like a populist politician might on Twitter, and he was “willing to take the criticism for them.”

Was he so young and naive that he did not know it would be more than just criticism? Did he not know he would lose everything, his life as he knew it? Or will he?

It became even stranger as we saw him on center stage at the International Summit on Human Genome Editing in Hong Kong led by the Nobel laureate, David Baltimore. There He Jiankui sat, defiant, his name tag dangling, a debilitating constant sniff betraying his fear: the modern Frankenstein facing the flash of a thousand cameras.

Maybe I had been right all those years. Frankenstein was indeed the monster after all. This young man had been created by the peers who now sat around him in judgement, questioning his every word, his every move. This was the trial of He Jiankui. He had become the creation, the monster. Did they know he was theirs?

What will the modern world do with the monster today?

After He Jiankui's personal appeal and before the inquisition, the Nobel laureate stood, the leader, the arbiter, looking at the floor--before anyone asked their questions--with his words of judgement, reflecting what the whole world felt: horror. “Irresponsible.”

Condemned.

"I feel strangely satisfied," tweeted Antonio Regalado.

“It’s dangerous, unethical, and represents a perilous new moment in human history,” said O. Carter Snead, a former presidential adviser on bioethics.

The full title of Mary Shelley’s book is Frankenstein, or The Modern Prometheus.

Prometheus was a trickster who went against the authority of the gods to give fire to humans. For this the Gods sentenced him to eternal torment. He was bound to a rock and pecked each day by a giant vulture who fed on his liver which was eaten only to grow back each day and eaten again.

Poor Jiankui.

His work is "justified,” says George Church of Harvard. “The genie is out of the bottle now.”

Promotheus was also remembered for his intelligence and for championing mankind.

He Jiankui has held fire, and there is something about fire, there is something about technology which burns through the hands of its creators. It must be controlled to be of use because it can enflame whole villages. Exhibit A: Facebook. Zuckerberg was not similarly condemned or shut down after his trial for what many are calling a humanitarian crisis that dwarfs the gene editing of two babies. This is not the crossing of the Rubicon as we have heard this week. That was a military, a political move. There was no new technology in Caesar's hands. This is that burst, that spark of the human mind, that tinkering that led to the first IVF baby.

Right now is the time to feel the shock, the condemnation, the wonder at the strangeness. But tomorrow we have to decide what to do with this story.

“This story is getting more sci-fi every minute. Michael Crichton couldn’t have made this stuff up,” tweeted Eric Topol of the Scripps.

Then Dr. Topol sent in an OpEd to the New York Times to explain to the public, to make his case that it is too early, that it is too risky. I admire Dr. Topol for reaching out to the public as a researcher and a doctor, for swiftly getting ahead of the story. However his opinion piece (or pick any one of a number of others from the head of the NIH to the FDA) is heavy handed and risks condemning the very technology which I know he is very excited about, the potential for genomic medicine to eradicate disease and ease human suffering.

I've seen a quote floating around by one of the inventors of the CRISPR technology, Jennifer Doudna, that her greatest fear is "waking up one morning and reading about the first CRISPR baby, and having that create a public backlash where people ban or regulators shut this down."

What story will we tell our friends and family? And I have to say that none of my friends or family have known about it until I told them.

If this story is not true, "it would be a pretty bald-faced fraud,” Hank Greely of Stanford told the Atlantic. “If it is true, I’m disappointed.”

Disappointment is a kind word. A parental feeling.

What do you feel? How will you frame this to your family and friends? Is it science fiction? Is He Jiankui a Frankenstein who will forever be chasing his monster? Or is he the monster created by others? Will those others now turn on him? Should this all be shut down, or is this one small step for man, and one giant leap for mankind?

Whatever story we choose, there are now two new characters that we must add: Lulu and Nana. I hope the world will be kind to them, that they will not end up lonely, isolated, and desirous of running away to the North Pole. They are no more strange than He Jiankui, or than the scientists who tamed this bacteria and archaea based tool suite CRISPR/Cas9, no more strange than you or me.

Comments

The issue here is the Chinese government strictly controls everything. Dr. He argues, there were no laws against editing human genomes, but the government will argue that since the technology is so new, the current laws surrounding cloning and other human medical treatments should be extended. The government will win. We no longer live in a society where you can use yourself or your children (or in this case, the children of others) to practice scientific exploration. There are rules and limits. Dr He will probably receive some form of punnishment.

Additionally since this is China, they will probably make sure the girls cannot reproduce by ordering them to be sterilized. And, they will be isolated their entire lives and treated like mice to monitor the progress of thepunishment. The girls will probably loose.

The Chinese government has power over individual rights greater than any country on the planet; so, Dr He ruined, not one, but three lives.

In the US, he may have personally suffered, but, the girls would've been scientific celebrities. But, China is not the US. George's premise is simply not correct, they may not be here...

jordancrum's picture

Frankenstein is a very specific character. Every reader can see himself in it. For example, I was able to spend the time with my life. I chose him as my character in an essay for https://vortexessay.com/. It turned out very well, not bad, my essay gathered positive reviews, and at the university I received A +. Read books and develop, it's great.

Roku is a streaming device, which is a reasonable https://sites.google.com/site/rokuactivationn/ and other Set-up Box. Roku is a bundle of amusement, where client can stream for boundless motion appears, web arrangement, news, animation and a lot more projects.

mcafee antivirus is a commonly used antivirus that detects and kills PC infections, enables mail worms, Trojan programs, and so on, making your [url=https://sites.google.com/site/commcafeecomactivate/] mcafee.com/activate[/url] infrastructure free of infections and other malware day-to-day challenges. makes. For more accurate travel download [url=https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeewwwmcafeecomactivate/]www.mcafee.com... Mcafee Antivirus to protect your PC or PC from infection and ensure data. mcafee activation can be easily processed using the activation code from the mcafee retail card and using it online on the Mcafee website page. Click our [url=https://sites.google.com/site/activatemcafeecomactivate/]mcafee.com/acti... link for more information.

mcafee antivirus is a commonly used antivirus that detects and kills PC infections, enables mail worms, Trojan programs, and so on, making your https://sites.google.com/site/commcafeecomactivate/ infrastructure free of infections and other malware day-to-day challenges. makes. For more accurate travel download https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeewwwmcafeecomactivate/ Mcafee Antivirus to protect your PC or PC from infection and ensure data. mcafee activation can be easily processed using the activation code from the mcafee retail card and using it online on the Mcafee website page. Click our https://sites.google.com/site/activatemcafeecomactivate/ link for more information.

Mcafee activation can be easily processed using activation code from mcafee retail card and using it online on Mcafee Website page. you can https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeactivateentercode/ download and activate security of your device online.mcafee antivirus is widely used a antivirus helps to detect and neutralize https://sites.google.com/site/downloadmcafeeactivationcode/ computer virus, the mail worms,the trojan programs,and also helps your system free of virus and This is very beneficial for you For more https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeinstallationproductkey/ information by visiting our website

Mcafee is a standout amongst the best antivirus to ensure your computer,laptop and Great software fromvirus attacks.Mcafee program Saves your PC from https://sites.google.com/site/ihavemcafeeproductkey/ infection. Mcafee activation can be easily processed using activation code from mcafee retail card and using it online on Mcafee Website page. you can download and activate security of your device online.And you can take advantage of it at the most For more https://sites.google.com/site/installmcafeeactivationcode/ information, visit the website

webroot is all time best protective antivirus and anti-software .It is real time protection technology and it is safer , faster and more complete than ever beforeYou can easily download and install https://sites.google.com/site/safewebrootcomsafe/ it Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus Pro Activation Key is extensive and the dependable ant-virus tool provides a superior safety to your pc from harmful risks And for more information related to this, our website https://sites.google.com/site/webrootactivation/ You can get information by

To enact Hulu Plus on your gadget, either utilize the on-screen console to enter your Hulu sign in data or go to https://sites.google.com/site/activatehulucomactivate/ and enter the gadget initiation code. Both of these strategies will enable you to utilize Hulu on any Hulu-upheld gadget Hulu is a standout amongst other gushing administrations that simplicity access to content on various sorts of gadgets. from https://sites.google.com/site/huluactivation/ You can stream crosswise over PCs, cell phones and gaming supports. and actuate your Hulu account Can do If you want to watch your favorite movies, TV shows or web series on a single platform, Then hulu the best option is you can download it easily And can https://sites.google.com/site/huluchannelactivation/ easily avail of it

norton User can protect their devices by regularly scanning https://sites.google.com/site/setupnortoncomsetup/ the computer with Norton antivirus. norton.com/setup anti-virus Existing uses virus definitions, suspicious behavior, emulation and antivirus gives the least demanding to utilize and most intutive assurance for your PC and your mobiles .introduce it and disregard viruses,spyware,root-units, hackers And easily https://sites.google.com/site/comnortoncomsetup/ take advantage of it

Roku provides the simplest way to stream entertainment to your TV. Thousands of https://sites.google.com/site/rokurokuactivation/channels available on this here. To watch favorite movies or web series on Roku Streaming Devices, user needs to create your Roku account at https://sites.google.com/site/linkyourrokudevice/ and completed a Roku account setup, and then complete an activation process to enter 6 digit Roku Link Code. To get roku link code, follow is the procedure to get roku link code. Sign in to your Roku account.And take https://sites.google.com/site/enterrokuactivationcodeonline/ advantage of it

A browser is required to facilitate access to any roku account, so at first open your web brower. Login your Roku account by https://sites.google.com/site/rokulinkactivaterokutv/ providing required details. Then, go to Player section to retrieve the link code. Once getting the roku link code, open Link your Roku device. All you need is an excellent connectivity of network and an account to https://sites.google.com/site/rorokuactivationenterlinkcode/ manage the entire entertainment field. Roku code link can be found in different forms like:TV sets, set-top boxes etc. For more information https://sites.google.com/site/rokuaccounsetup/ visit our website

Through Roku we can Netflix, CBS, NBC, HBO, and many more connect to many https://sites.google.com/site/rokulinkcodefromtv/
streaming services like. One can get the benefit of many Roku channels.Get the benefit of many hit movies and TV shows and live news every day https://sites.google.com/site/rokuenteractivationcodeforroku/ website On reaching Then, go to the submit button. Now, Select a channel by Roku remote and according to your choice which you want to watch and like.Roku account creation ·For more https://sites.google.com/site/linkrokulinktoentermycode/ information visit our website

roku.com/link Activate roku from https://sites.google.com/site/rokuactivatemyrokucode/ Enter the roku activation code at and enable the roku streaming device or TV. roku activation code or Roku link code is the code used for activating the roku device. To activate your Roku streaming device you will need a Roku Account. There are two options to making your free Roku account. You can either create it upfront on my.roku.com/signup or when you begin the activation process of your Roku streaming device. The activation process for your Roku streaming device is very straight-forward and easy.

Security, in any form, is an important part https://sites.google.com/site/downloadmcafeealreadypurchased/
of every activity. We put locks on our house, pattern lock on our phone, & take every possible measure to ensure safety. The leading antivirus software that has strong presence is McAfee. To get McAfee protection, you can buy it from https://sites.google.com/site/activatemymcafeeproductkey/ web or any retail store. And get the benefit of it McAfee installation with product key Mcafee activates is the safest and best product for home and business users. This can help you to install McAfee activate on your https://sites.google.com/site/activatemcafeeactivationcode/ system and Mac.

Setup mcafee antivirus by visiting https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivatekeycode/and mcafee enter product key code.Enter 25 digit Activation Code Mcafee 25 digit Activation Code Mcafee is Link to activate Mcafee Product subscription, click link https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeemcafeeproductactivation/ and visit mcafee website to enter activation code.In order to activate your Mcafee Antivirus Product, it must be linked to a Mcafee account with Mcafee Product Key and visit here more details Setup mcafee antivirus by visiting mcafee.com/activate and mcafee enter product key code.Enter 25 digit Activation Code Mcafee 25 digit Activation Code Mcafee is Link to activate Mcafee Product subscription, activate your Mcafee Antivirus Product, For more information, visit https://sites.google.com/site/howtoinstallmcafeeantivirus/ the link given

introduce or download the Mcafee antivirus program, since it is incredibly gainful and helpful programming that https://sites.google.com/site/howtoinstallmcafeeonwindows10/ can experience infections or dangers and can undoubtedly battle and wipe out yourself likewise on the PC gadget and Enter McAfee Product key and Activate https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeactivationcode/ By visiting, the client can show more details without starting the Stretch Download Introduction to Macafee Antivirus from its official network. Mcafee.com/activate - mcafee provides online protection, virus scanning, threats blocking and many more other features. www.mcafee.com/activate with the help of product key or 25 digit mcafee activation code https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivatemyaccoun/ download, install do

Presently, technology is transforming at a quicker pace than ever. With all the growth in technology comes the https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecommcafeecomactivate/\ increasing number of possibilities for cybercriminals to abuse. McAfee antivirus Is most useful https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomwwwmcafeecomactivate/ to stop them all With McAfee antivirus installed on their devices, users can heave a sigh of relief. McAfee antivirus ensures that all harmful entities stay away from the device. If it detects any unusual or malicious activity, it immediately notifies the user and blocks it. Users can purchase McAfee from the web by going to https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeemcafeemcafeecomactivate/ And get the benefit of it

McAfee.com/activate – The expansion of negative components over the web has prompted the https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeemcafeemcafeecomactivate/ developing interest for antiviruses. The entirety of our basic work, for example, net banking, installments, correspondence, information move, and in any event, shopping, is being done through mcafee Ideal for https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivatetotalprotecti/
families with an assortment of gadgets, McAfee Total Protection gives Windows, Mac and https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivateenterkey/ versatile infection assurance, spam separating capacities, Provides

Mcafee.com/activate –With the increasing cyber crime rate, the necessity of a https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivateproductkey/
trusted antivirus has increased altogether. Big companies and businesses generally face consequences of cyber attacks, whether it is financial or private. As a measure of data protection, not only https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivatetotalprotecti/ companies but also every person is now relying on McAfee. https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivateenterkey/ Antivirus is a software that provides a wide variety of virus detection methods as it not only prevents viruses from entering your computer system but kills or quarantines viruses that have broken through the firewall.

To activate Mcafee product key visit https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivatelivesafe/ and verify product key or Get support for Mcafee download, install and online activation. If you do not have Mcafee subscription do not worry, sign in and download and follow steps for Activate. Here is the guide to download, install and activate mcafee using 25 digit mcafee activate product key from https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivateurl/ USA.Mcafee antivirus not only saves you from virus and malware attacks but also take care of your cyber security and online transactions. At the backside of the retail card, or in the order confirmation mail, there shall be a download link such as mcafee.com/activate. Enter the link in the web browser. Now, you need to choose the country language of the McAfee antivirus you have bought. Click on the drop-down menu located in the center of the display and chose the language.And take https://sites.google.com/site/sitemcafeecomactivate/ advantage of it

Install Mcafee antivirus on your PC, Mac or mobile device Install MacAfee with retail card product key You can open https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivatelogin\ on google then click on mcafee.com/activate from your computer Then submit you 25 digit retail card product key, you can proceed and download https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivateusa/ file Enter code for mcafee. www.mcafee.com/activate is the best digital security tool for home and business uses to save your important data and devices from virus Setup mcafee antivirus by visiting mcafee.com/activate and mcafee enter product key code. This Mcafee Activation Code is 25-digit alphanumeric unique code. You should keep your mcafee product key https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeecomactivatecard/ safe and accessible to you.

McAfee Activate – The threat posed by computer viruses, malware, and cybercrimes is not unknown to us. But due to negligence, many people take no precautions to deal with it. Despite adequate knowledge, we often underestimate the fact that nothing will ever happen to our devices. It’s an old saying that “Prevention is always better than cure”. Hence, it becomes very essential to protect your devices with good security https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeactivationkey/ solutions like McAfee as it’s truly the best you can find.McAfee does completely protect and secure https://sites.google.com/site/entercodeformcafee/ your computer and data from the infections, malware, etc. To get started with it visit www.mcafee.com/activate, and log in or sign up to your McAfee account. This link will also help you redeem your McAfee activation code. Now, you need to download the setup and begin https://sites.google.com/site/enterproductkeyformcafee/ with your McAfee antivirus experience.

Get started with product security.download mcafee with https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeactivationcodeentry/ and https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeantiviruscodeentry/ .to get more information,visit the website https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeproductcodeactivation/ given by us and learn about mcafee antivirus

Visit mcafee.com/enact to recover your membership now. The 25-digit McAfee Activation Code The McAfee order code is a 25-character alphanumeric key used to recuperate McAfee enrollments.For more https://sites.google.com/site/mcafeeenteractivationcode/ information visit our website

Webroot activation keycode is very vital for installing and activating the https://sites.google.com/site/webrootactivationwithkeycode/
Webroot software. It comes in the set of 20 alphanumeric characters. You can easily find this code in your inbox or check the retail card. You may also log in to your https://sites.google.com/site/webrootdownloadkeycodebestbuy/ Webroot account at www.webroot.com/safe and get the keycode.Webroot is quick and easy to download, install, and run. Plus, updates are automatic so you always have the most current protection. For more information visit https://sites.google.com/site/webrootdownloadalreadypurchase/ our website

Webroot Antivirus security package is very easy to install, setup & Activate with the link . Webroot antivirus is easy to download. Along with this, its updates also run automatically, so that you can be protected from https://sites.google.com/site/wdownloadwebrootwithkeycode/ the obstacles coming to you. Webroot Support experts can lend their hand to download, install and update Webroot Spy Sweeper Antivirus on your system. We can also repair all errors that may crop up while installing and configuring Webroot Antivirus on your PC. We can help you detect and remove malicious threats, malware and spyware by performing a quick scan on all files and folders. With our robust technology, we can …If you have already downloaded the Webroot file, then https://sites.google.com/site/webrootbestbuydownloadwindows/ proceed further towards its installation process. Go to the Internet Browser. Navigate webroot.com/safe through the URL tab. Select either Business or Home from the appeared icons For more information please https://sites.google.com/site/downloadwebrootalreadyhavekey/ visit our website

Best buy webroot install download Install and Activate Webroot at best buy webroot install Safe is the https://sites.google.com/site/bestbuywebrootinstalldownload/ most popular computer security that helps you https://sites.google.com/site/bestbuywebrootinstall/ to protect Windows,Mac and Android devices. Webroot protection is quick and easy to download, install, and run, so you don't have to wait around to be fully protected. Plus, it updates itself automatically without slowing you or your system down, so you always have the most current protection.

To Install AVG with license number, the user must purchase a license of Avg antivirus from https://sites.google.com/site/avgdownloadwithlicensenumber/ the retail store or online. Though download AVG software is the easiest process, Reach the page https://sites.google.com/site/avgretailactivationpage/ and activate the AVG retail antivirus with the installation. You can also go through www.avg.com/activation to activate the downloaded AVG setup on your computer. Here you must enter the unique AVG activation code so that you can successfully shield your data from multiple viruses and threats in a single scan For more information please https://sites.google.com/site/howtodownloadandinstallavg/ visit our website

Avg retail activation page – Protect your Computer from the latest threats and Internet Hackers Spyware and https://sites.google.com/site/avginternetlicenseactivation/ adware may damage your computer system and crucial data. Therefore, today it is so crucial to have good security protection that could protect your offline and online digital daily life.AVG Free is easy to download and install. When your installation is arranged, the will be downloaded and installed consequently. This may take a few minutes relying upon your PC speed and system association. Restart your PC to finish the installation For more information please visit our website.

Log in to your Norton account Sign in to enter your product key, access your account, manage your subscription, and extend your Norton protection to PC, Mac, Android, and iOS devices. If you don't already have a Norton account, create one today. Norton download can be easily done by https://sites.google.com/site/nortonmyaccoun/
following the instructions given below: Go to and click Sign in. After logging in, you will see the Get Started page. Here, you need to click on the Download Norton option How to Install Norton Setup on Android. Learn about the download install https://sites.google.com/site/downloadnortonhaveproductkey/ and activation of Norton for Android devices through below mentioned points. Open your Android device. Launch Google Play Store. Type Norton into search panel. Ensure to read Terms and Condition of Norton. Tap on agree. Submit the credentials of Norton account into text area. Norton is successfully installed For more information please visit https://sites.google.com/site/howtodownloadnortonsetup/ our website

Norton setup If you want to use the Norton Antivirus services to protect your device, you have to complete the Norton setup. It is the process where you install and activate the Norton product on your device.The Norton Product Key is an alphanumeric key of 25 characters that comes in handy for downloading, installing, and then installing Norton, which is more needed when a user https://sites.google.com/site/ssetupnorton/norton-setup-product-key wants to subscribe to Norton or activate the plan. Norton setup enter product key is searched in two ways

" />


New to Mendelspod?

We advance life science research, connecting people and ideas.
Register here to receive our newsletter.

or skip signup